Last Updated: November 17, 2026
The featured image is an AI-generated illustration of the products discussed. We did not physically test them. Appearance and colors may vary. The illustration is not to scale.
Makers’ official pages, help-center answers, and user manuals checked November 16, 2026. We did not test these litter boxes; we compared what the makers publish.
AI disclosure: BestPetPicker Research prepared this page with AI assistance and checked each fact against the maker pages listed under Sources.
Self-cleaning litter boxes use supplies you replace over time: bags or liners, crystal trays, carbon filters, and odor packs (optional on some models). This guide lists those refills for six of the seven models in our comparison of self-cleaning litter box designs: what each maker sells or allows, how often it says to change each item, and which refills fit which boxes. For the seventh, the CATLINK Open-X, ask CATLINK. For how the designs work and which litter each box takes, see that comparison; this page covers the refills.
Short answers
- Only the maker’s own: PetSafe tells Crystal Pro owners to “use only authentic PetSafe® ScoopFree® Crystal Litter Trays” and says “the litter box will not function with other litter trays.”
- The maker’s own, per its manual: PETKIT’s MAX PRO 2 manual says, “Please use the PETKIT specialized trash bag.” For other bags, ask PETKIT.
- Any bag that fits, the maker’s bags recommended: the FAQ on Neakasa’s M1 Plus product page says, “Yes, you can use any bag that fits in the waste drawer.” Asked “Is it necessary to use your brand of garbage bags?”, Neakasa’s help center answers, “We recommend using Neakasa brand garbage bags, which are more compatible with the cat litter box.”
- Any bag that fits: for the Litter-Robot 4, Whisker says “you can use any bag that fits in the waste drawer.” For the most precise drawer readings, it adds, “we highly recommend using Litter-Robot Waste Drawer Liners.”
- Shared refills: one PetSafe deodorizer 2-pack fits both the SmartSpin and the OpenSky, but PetSafe’s two liner packs don’t swap: the 25-pack is for the SmartSpin and the 15-pack is for the OpenSky only. Both boxes come with bags; for other bags, ask PetSafe. Whisker’s liners fit any Litter-Robot; its carbon filters fit the Litter-Robot 4, 5/Pro, and EVO, but not the Litter-Robot 3.
- How many a year: by our count, a Crystal Pro goes through about 12–18 disposable trays a year with one cat and about 24–37 with two, from PetSafe’s 20–30 and 10–15 day figures.
- Bags, one cat: by the makers’ one-cat figures, every 1 to 2 weeks (OpenSky once every 2 weeks, Neakasa M1 every 7 to 10 days, Litter-Robot 4 every 8 days to weekly, SmartSpin about weekly), or about 26 to 52 bags a year by our count. Whisker’s carbon filter adds about 12 to 26 a year.
Models covered (maker’s code): Whisker Litter-Robot 4 (U.S. codes such as LR4-0101-00-US) · PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro (PAL00-18017) · PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin (PAL00-17985) · PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky (ZAL00-18120) · Neakasa M1 Plus · PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 (P9904) · CATLINK Scooper Open-X (ask CATLINK).
Bags and liners
| Model | Bag or liner (maker’s rule) | When to change it (maker) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Litter-Robot 4 | Whisker Waste Drawer Liners (5 in the box), or any bag that fits; Whisker says dark bags can make drawer-level readings inaccurate | Each time you empty the drawer: as seldom as every 8 days for 1 cat (Litter-Robot 4 FAQ), half that for each added cat (lineup page); twice a week is typical for 2 average-sized cats (liner page) | S6S1S5S7 |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | ScoopFree Waste Bin Liners (25 per pack); bags come in the box; for other bags, ask PetSafe | About once a week for 1 cat, twice a week for 2 (user guide) | S20S9 |
| PetSafe OpenSky | OpenSky Waste Bin Liners (15 per pack), made for the OpenSky only; bags come in the box; for other bags, ask PetSafe | Once every 2 weeks for 1 cat, 1 to 2 times a week for 2 (user guide) | S21S11 |
| Neakasa M1 Plus | Any bag that fits, says the product page FAQ; Neakasa recommends its own bags (330 mm x 690 mm); the M1 box has two 15-bag rolls | Every 7 to 10 days for 1 cat, no longer than 14 days (M1 manual); for 2 cats, ask Neakasa | S24S25S23S29 |
| PETKIT MAX PRO 2 | PETKIT trash bag (listed in the box); the manual says to use PETKIT’s specialized bag; for other bags, ask PETKIT | When the app shows “Waste bin full” | S27 |
The Crystal Pro has trays instead: PetSafe’s guide says, “Remove the lid from under the tray and use it to cover the tray for disposal.” The version sold with cleanup bags “does not include a lid”; PetSafe says to “place the entire tray into the disposal bag”. Its trays are in the next table.
Trays, filters, and odor packs
| Model | Item (maker’s rule) | When to change it (maker) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Litter-Robot 4 | Litter-Robot Carbon Filter (one in the box); for other filters, ask Whisker | Every month (filter page) or every 2–4 weeks (FAQ); more often with scented litter | S6S2S5 |
| Litter-Robot 4 | OdorTrap Packs, optional; without the holder, they go in the drawer after the liner | Every 2 weeks (OdorTrap page) or every 2–4 weeks (FAQ) | S6S4S5 |
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | ScoopFree disposable crystal trays (packs of 1, 3, or 6; also 2, 4, or 6 with cleanup bags); PetSafe says to use only authentic PetSafe trays | 20–30 days for 1 cat, 10–15 days for 2 (user guide); “up to 30 days” for a single cat (tray pages) | S13S14S15S16S8 |
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | ScoopFree reusable tray (stainless steel or plastic), filled with PetSafe crystal litter; PetSafe says the tray won’t void the warranty | Ask PetSafe how often to refill it | S17S18S19 |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | PetSafe deodorizer, optional; deodorizers come in the box | Up to 15 days each (deodorizer page) | S9S22 |
| PetSafe OpenSky | The same PetSafe deodorizer as the SmartSpin, optional; a deodorizer comes in the box | Up to 15 days each (deodorizer page) | S22S11 |
| PETKIT MAX PRO 2 | N50 2.0 odor eliminator for the waste bin (in the box) | When the app shows “N50 remaining 0 day” | S27 |
| PETKIT MAX PRO 2 | N60 for the Breezy smart odor eliminator (in the box) | When the app shows “N60 has expired” | S27 |
Whisker’s Litter-Robot 4 page calls the OdorTrap Packs “optional,” and PetSafe’s guides say, “If desired, remove and replace the waste drawer deodorizer.”
About how many a year
Our count divides 365 days by the maker’s own interval and rounds to the nearest whole number. It is our arithmetic on the makers’ intervals. Where the maker’s figure is “up to,” expect that many or more.
| Item | Maker’s interval | About how many a year (our count) | Source (maker interval) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crystal Pro trays, 1 cat | 20–30 days | ≈12–18 | S8 |
| Crystal Pro trays, 2 cats | 10–15 days | ≈24–37 | S8 |
| Litter-Robot 4 liners or bags, 1 cat | Every 8 days (FAQ) to weekly (liner page) | ≈46–52 | S5S1 |
| Litter-Robot 4 liners or bags, 2 cats | Half of 8 days per added cat (lineup page) to twice a week for 2 average-sized cats (liner page) | ≈91–104 | S7S5S1 |
| Litter-Robot 4 carbon filters | Every month to every 2 weeks | ≈12–26 | S2S5 |
| OdorTrap packs (optional) | Every 2 weeks (OdorTrap page) to every 4 weeks (FAQ) | ≈13–26 | S4S5 |
| SmartSpin bags or liners, 1 cat | About once a week (user guide) | ≈52 | S9 |
| SmartSpin bags or liners, 2 cats | Twice a week (user guide) | ≈104 | S9 |
| OpenSky bags or liners, 1 cat | Once every 2 weeks | ≈26 | S11 |
| OpenSky bags or liners, 2 cats | 1 to 2 times a week | ≈52–104 | S11 |
| PetSafe deodorizers (optional) | Up to 15 days each | ≈24 or more | S22 |
| Neakasa M1 Plus bags, 1 cat | Every 7 to 10 days | ≈37–52 | S23S29 |
PETKIT’s manual ties the MAX PRO 2’s bag, N50, and N60 changes to app messages; to plan ahead, ask PETKIT how long each one usually lasts. For the CATLINK Open-X, ask CATLINK which bags and other refills fit and how often to change them.
Which refills fit which boxes
| Refill | Fits (per the maker) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Whisker Waste Drawer Liners | Any Litter-Robot: 5/Pro, EVO, 4, 3 (with or without Connect), and 2 | S1 |
| Litter-Robot Carbon Filters | Litter-Robot 4, 5/Pro, and EVO; not the Litter-Robot 3 or 3 Connect | S2 |
| Whisker OdorTrap Packs | Any Litter-Robot | S4 |
| PetSafe ScoopFree disposable crystal trays | All ScoopFree Crystal self-cleaning boxes (tray pages); the Crystal Pro guide says to use only authentic ScoopFree Crystal trays | S13S8 |
| PetSafe ScoopFree reusable trays | All ScoopFree Crystal boxes | S17S18 |
| PetSafe ScoopFree Waste Bin Liners (25) | SmartSpin and the ScoopFree Clumping box; not ScoopFree Crystal boxes | S20 |
| PetSafe OpenSky Waste Bin Liners (15) | OpenSky only; not ScoopFree Crystal boxes | S21 |
| PetSafe SmartSpin and OpenSky deodorizers (2-pack) | SmartSpin and OpenSky | S22 |
| Neakasa garbage bags (330 mm x 690 mm) | Neakasa M1: the product page FAQ says “you can use any bag that fits in the waste drawer”; the help center says Neakasa’s bags are “more compatible with the cat litter box” | S25S24S29 |
| PETKIT trash bag, N50 2.0, and N60 | Listed in the MAX PRO 2 box (manual) | S27 |
Each row follows the maker’s own compatibility statement or package list. Before you buy a refill for a box outside its row, ask the maker.
Model by model: what the makers say
Whisker Litter-Robot 4
- Bags: Whisker’s FAQ says, “No, Litter-Robot does not require special bags or liners for the waste drawer. As long as it fits, you can use it.” Whisker’s own liners come in packs of 10, 25, or 50, and “five come free with each Litter-Robot”.
- When: “Replace the liner whenever you need to empty the waste drawer.” For the Litter-Robot 4, Whisker says the drawer “may only need to be emptied once every 8 days in a one-cat household,” and “The exact frequency depends on the number and size of your cats, as well as their litter habits.” The box tells you, too: “Litter-Robot will notify you when the waste drawer is full”.
- Carbon filter: one comes in the box (“Includes a fence, step, carbon filter & waste drawer liners (5)”). Whisker’s filter page says “Replace the Carbon Filter every month (recommended)” and “If you use scented litter, we recommend changing the filter more often as it will also absorb the litter scent.” Filters come in packs of 2 or 6.
- OdorTrap Packs: Whisker’s Litter-Robot 4 page says, “Add the optional OdorTrap™ Packs to further neutralize litter box odors.” Without the holder, “place OdorTrap Packs in the waste drawer after a liner has been installed.” Packs come in 3, 6, or 12.
- Our Litter-Robot 4 review covers the rest of the box; Whisker’s litter rules are in our design comparison.
PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro
- Trays: PetSafe’s user guide says, “Remember to use only authentic PetSafe® ScoopFree® Crystal Litter Trays with your PetSafe® ScoopFree® Crystal Pro Hooded Self-Cleaning Litter Box.” Disposable trays come in packs of 1, 3, or 6; a second version comes in packs of 2, 4, or 6 and includes a disposal bag.
- When: “You can expect a litter tray to last 20-30 days for one cat, 10-15 days for two cats, and 7-10 days for three or more cats.” PetSafe’s 1-pack tray page puts it as “Lasts up to 30 days in a single-cat home”.
- Reusable trays: PetSafe’s stainless steel tray “is compatible with all ScoopFree® Crystal Litter Box systems,” and PetSafe says the tray “won’t void your warranty.” You fill it yourself: PetSafe’s support steps begin, “Pour PetSafe® Crystal Litter into the reusable litter tray,” and “Additional pre-portioned refill bags are available to purchase.” PetSafe also sells a plastic “ScoopFree® Reusable Tray with Crystal Litter”. For how often to refill a reusable tray, or whether another crystal litter works in it, ask PetSafe.
- Our Crystal Pro vs. SmartSpin comparison walks through the tray routine step by step.
PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin and OpenSky
- Bags: both user guides say, “Line the waste drawer with one of the waste bags provided.” For refills, PetSafe sells two different liners: a 25-pack that is “only compatible with the ScoopFree® Clumping Self-Cleaning Litter Box and ScoopFree® SmartSpin™ Self-Cleaning Litter Box,” and a 15-pack that is “only compatible with the ScoopFree® OpenSky Self-Cleaning Litter Box”. For other bags, ask PetSafe.
- When: the SmartSpin guide says, “You can expect to empty the waste drawer about once a week for one cat, twice a week for two cats, or every few days for three or more cats.” The OpenSky guide says “once every 2 weeks for one cat, 1 to 2 times a week for two cats, or every few days for three or more cats.” PetSafe’s OpenSky liner page says each liner “Holds up to two weeks of waste”.
- Deodorizers: one 2-pack fits both boxes. PetSafe says “Each deodorizer lasts up to 15 days,” and both guides say, “If desired, remove and replace the waste drawer deodorizer.”
- Litter: the OpenSky guide warns, “Litter with larger pellets, such as pine or tofu litter, may not be compatible with the litter box.” If you use pine or tofu litter, ask PetSafe first. The design comparison covers the other litter rules.
Neakasa M1 Plus
Neakasa’s facts here come from its M1 user manual, the M1 section of its help center, and the FAQ on its product page, which sells this model as the M1 Plus (S29). Neakasa says “the M1 and M1 Lite also feature variations in the Odor-Seal Electric Door and accessories,” so check which version you have before you buy refills.
- Bags: the FAQ on Neakasa’s product page says, “Yes, you can use any bag that fits in the waste drawer.” Asked “Is it necessary to use your brand of garbage bags?”, Neakasa’s help center answers, “We recommend using Neakasa brand garbage bags, which are more compatible with the cat litter box.” Neakasa gives the size as “Garbage bag size: 330mm x 690mm.” The M1 manual lists “Trash Bags (15 pieces/roll) x2” in the box.
- When: “Empty the waste bin every 7 to 10 days for a cat, and no longer than 14 days.” For two cats, ask Neakasa.
PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2
- In the box: the manual’s package list includes a trash bag, the “Pet Odor Eliminator N50 2.0”, and the “Pet Odor Eliminator N60 (Used in the smart odor eliminator)”.
- Bags: “Please use the PETKIT specialized trash bag.” For other bags, ask PETKIT. When the app shows “Waste bin full”, “please replace the trash bag with a new one.”
- N50 and N60: replace the N50 when the app shows “N50 remaining 0 day” and the N60 when it shows “N60 has expired”. The manual’s maintenance page adds “(Please replace it regularly)”. To plan how many to keep on hand, ask PETKIT how long each one lasts.
Where one maker gives two answers
- Litter-Robot carbon filter: the filter page says “every month”; Whisker’s FAQ says “every 2-4 weeks”. Both add that “replacement frequency is up to you and your cats’ usage patterns”. Our count uses the whole range: about 12 to 26 filters a year.
- OdorTrap Packs: the OdorTrap page says “Replace pack every two weeks”; the FAQ says every 2–4 weeks; Whisker’s quantity guide lists “6-Pack / 3 months” for 1 to 4 cats. Our count uses the whole range: about 13 to 26 a year.
- Litter-Robot 4 drawer, two cats: Whisker’s lineup page says single-cat homes empty the drawer “approximately” as follows, “Litter-Robot 4, every 8 days,” and “For every additional cat, divide that figure in half.” Its liner page says, “For two average-sized cats, twice per week is typical.” Our count uses the whole range: about 91 to 104 liners a year.
- SmartSpin bags: the product page says, “Every couple of weeks, refill the litter box with your cat’s favorite litter and replace the waste bin drawer with a new liner.” The user guide says “about once a week for one cat”. Our count uses the guide’s one-cat figure.
- Neakasa waste bin, one cat: the M1 manual says, “Empty the waste bin every 7 to 10 days for a cat, and no longer than 14 days.” The FAQ on Neakasa’s product page says, “Usually you only need to empty the waste container about 14 days for one cat.” Our count uses the manual’s figure: about 37 to 52 bags a year.
FAQ
Can I use kitchen trash bags in a Litter-Robot 4?
Whisker says yes: “Customers often use 10- to 13-gallon kitchen garbage bags or large plastic grocery bags.” It also notes that “waste level readings may be inaccurate when using a dark bag, especially when the drawer is empty,” and says of its own liners, “White color improves accuracy of waste drawer level readings”.
Can the Crystal Pro use a reusable tray instead of disposable trays?
Yes. PetSafe sells reusable trays for all ScoopFree Crystal boxes. You fill them with PetSafe crystal litter, which PetSafe sells in pre-portioned refill bags; see the Crystal Pro notes above.
Switching from a Litter-Robot 3: which refills carry over?
Whisker’s liners fit both: “any Litter-Robot 5/Pro, Litter-Robot EVO, Litter-Robot 4, Litter-Robot 3 (with or without Connect), or Litter-Robot 2.” Its current carbon filters “are not compatible with older models, including Litter-Robot 3 and Litter-Robot 3 Connect,” so ask Whisker before you move filters between boxes. Still deciding whether to upgrade? See our Litter-Robot 3 Connect guide.
Do these counts include litter?
Not separately. The counts cover bags, liners, trays, filters, and odor packs. PetSafe’s disposable Crystal Pro trays come with their crystal litter (the 1-pack lists “1 bag (4.3 lb) of Premium Crystal Litter”), so the tray count is also your crystal-litter count. For the other boxes’ litter rules, see our design comparison.
Related guides
- Self-cleaning litter boxes: open top, covered, or crystal tray? The seven designs and each maker’s litter rules.
- Litter-Robot 4 alternatives: other self-cleaning boxes compared with the Litter-Robot 4.
- Automatic litter boxes for multiple cats: cat counts and how the boxes tell cats apart.
- PetSafe Crystal Pro vs. SmartSpin: the tray routine and the bag routine.
Sources
- S1. Whisker: Waste Drawer Liners (checked November 16, 2026)
- S2. Whisker: Litter-Robot Carbon Filters (checked November 16, 2026)
- S3. Whisker: Litter-Robot 4 Carbon Filters; background — not used for a table value (checked November 16, 2026)
- S4. Whisker: OdorTrap Packs (checked November 16, 2026)
- S5. Whisker: Litter-Robot FAQ (checked November 16, 2026)
- S6. Whisker: Litter-Robot 4 product page (checked November 16, 2026)
- S7. Whisker: Litter-Robot lineup page (checked November 16, 2026)
- S8. PetSafe: Crystal Pro user guide (PDF) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S9. PetSafe: SmartSpin user guide (PDF) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S10. PetSafe: SmartSpin product page; used in “Where one maker gives two answers” (checked November 16, 2026)
- S11. PetSafe: OpenSky user guide (PDF) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S12. PetSafe: OpenSky support page; links to the OpenSky user guide (S11) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S13. PetSafe: disposable crystal trays, 1-pack (checked November 16, 2026)
- S14. PetSafe: disposable crystal trays, 3-pack (checked November 16, 2026)
- S15. PetSafe: disposable crystal trays, 6-pack (checked November 16, 2026)
- S16. PetSafe: trays with cleanup bags (checked November 16, 2026)
- S17. PetSafe: stainless steel reusable tray (checked November 16, 2026)
- S18. PetSafe: reusable tray with crystal litter (checked November 16, 2026)
- S19. PetSafe: using the reusable tray with the Crystal Pro (checked November 16, 2026)
- S20. PetSafe: ScoopFree Waste Bin Liners; the compatibility answer is in the FAQ on that page (checked November 16, 2026)
- S21. PetSafe: OpenSky Waste Bin Liners; the compatibility answer is in the FAQ on that page (checked November 16, 2026)
- S22. PetSafe: SmartSpin and OpenSky deodorizers (checked November 16, 2026)
- S23. Neakasa: M1 user manual (PDF) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S24. Neakasa: help center, Neakasa brand garbage bags (checked November 16, 2026)
- S25. Neakasa: help center, trash bag size (checked November 16, 2026)
- S26. Neakasa: help center, M1 and M1 Lite; used in the Neakasa M1 Plus model notes (checked November 16, 2026)
- S27. PETKIT: PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 user manual (PDF) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S28. PETKIT: manual downloads page; links to the MAX PRO 2 user manual (S27) (checked November 16, 2026)
- S29. Neakasa: Neakasa M1 product page; source for the “M1 Plus” name and the bag and waste-bin answers in its FAQ (checked November 17, 2026)
We did not test these litter boxes. Refills, pack sizes, and intervals come from each maker’s pages and manuals on the date shown and can change; check the maker’s current page for your exact model before you buy. For questions about your cat’s health or litter box habits, ask your veterinarian.
To cite these tables: BestPetPicker Research, “Self-Cleaning Litter Box Supplies: Bags, Trays, Filters by Model,” https://bestpetpicker.com/self-cleaning-litter-box-supplies/ (checked November 16, 2026). To link one table, add its anchor, for example #compat-table.
Change log
- November 9, 2026 — Published.
- November 13, 2026 — Replaced the featured image with an AI-generated illustration and added a note saying so.
- November 14, 2026 — Added “The illustration is not to scale.”
- November 17, 2026 — Added a Source column to each table, table anchors, numbered sources, the Neakasa product page as a source for the “M1 Plus” name, a citation line, and this change log. The maker pages and manuals behind every table row and every quote on this page were re-checked on November 16, 2026. No table values changed.
- November 17, 2026 — Added the answers from the FAQ on Neakasa’s product page (S29) on other bags and on how often to empty the bin, next to the help center and manual answers, and moved Neakasa to “Any bag that fits, the maker’s bags recommended” in the short answers. The FAQ was checked on November 17, 2026.