Last Updated: November 17, 2026
The featured image is an AI-generated illustration of two of the products discussed, not a photo of units we handled. We did not physically test them. Appearance, colors and scale may vary.
Maker specs and policies checked November 3, 2026 (one Whisker FAQ on November 2; PetSafe’s Crystal Pro and SmartSpin user guides and reusable-tray page on October 28; the OpenSky user guide, the Neakasa and PETKIT user manuals, Neakasa’s bag help article, and Whisker’s carbon filter pages on November 9). Amazon sellers checked November 3, 2026.
AI disclosure: BestPetPicker Research prepared this page with AI assistance and checked each fact against the maker pages listed under Sources.
Quick answer: Pick the design before the model. If you want no app and would rather swap disposable trays than handle litter and bags, a crystal-tray box such as the PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro fits — but it takes only PetSafe’s own trays: you replace a disposable ScoopFree tray, or refill PetSafe’s reusable tray with crystal litter (PetSafe sells pre-portioned refill bags). If your cat avoids covered boxes, start with the open-top models: the PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky, the Neakasa M1 Plus, and the CATLINK Scooper Open-X. If you want a covered box that takes ordinary clumping litter, compare the Litter-Robot 4, the PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin, and the PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2. Then check four things before you buy: the litter the maker allows, the Wi-Fi band the app needs, the maker’s kitten rule, and who is selling the listing.
We did not test these litter boxes. We compared what each maker publishes on its product pages, FAQs, and policy pages, plus PetSafe’s user guides for three models, the Neakasa and PETKIT user manuals, and the Amazon U.S. listings we link (model numbers and sellers only). Figures such as “up to two weeks” between drawer emptyings are the makers’ own claims.
Have more than one cat? Our multi-cat guide covers cat counts and how the Litter-Robot and PETKIT models tell cats apart. This guide doesn’t repeat that.
The seven models by design
| Model | Design (maker’s wording) | Litter (maker) | App and Wi-Fi (maker) |
|---|---|---|---|
| PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro | Removable hood | PetSafe ScoopFree crystal trays only (disposable or reusable) | No app in PetSafe’s chart; usage counter on the box |
| PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky | Open top | “Most clumping litter types” | App, 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi |
| PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin | Spherical | Clumping litter in PetSafe’s chart (see below) | App, 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi |
| Whisker Litter-Robot 4 | Globe | Clumping clay recommended | App, 2.4 GHz only |
| PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 | Enclosed | Most clumping litter, with two sifters for coarse or fine litter | App, 2.4 or 5 GHz |
| Neakasa M1 Plus | Open top | Clumping or scoopable litter | App; ask Neakasa which Wi-Fi band it needs |
| CATLINK Scooper Open-X | Open design | Clumping litter (the page gives two versions of the rule — see below) | App, 2.4 or 5 GHz |
Decision 1: Crystal trays or clumping litter
This choice decides what you keep buying after the box itself.
Crystal tray (Crystal Pro). The tray holds both the litter and the waste. PetSafe’s product page says a tray lasts up to 30 days and that a light on the box tells you when to replace it; its user guide puts one tray at 20–30 days for one cat. PetSafe says the Crystal Pro works only with its official ScoopFree crystal trays, disposable or reusable. With disposable trays, each refill is a new ScoopFree tray; for its reusable tray, PetSafe sells pre-portioned crystal litter refill bags. PetSafe sells a litter subscription on its own site. Our Crystal Pro vs. SmartSpin comparison walks through the tray routine.
Clumping litter (the other six). You pick the litter within each maker’s rules, the box sifts clumps into a drawer, and you bag the waste. The rules differ:
- Litter-Robot 4: Whisker recommends clumping clay litter. It says plant-based litters “typically do not work,” and that strictly absorbent, non-clumping or loose-clumping, newspaper-based, and absorbent wood pellet litters don’t work. Some silica gel beads and crystals can be used if they pass through the screen, but Whisker doesn’t recommend translucent or white litter because it can affect the litter-level and drawer-full readings.
- Neakasa M1 Plus: clumping or scoopable litter, but not highly absorbent, non-clumping, loosely clumping, newspaper, or wood pellet types. The filter sifts particles up to 3 mm in diameter and 10 mm long. Neakasa says the first fill takes about 5–6 kg of litter (roughly 11–13 lb).
- PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2: “most clumping cat litter,” with one included sifter for larger particles such as tofu and mixed litter and another for finer bentonite and mineral/clay litter. PETKIT advises against litter longer than 0.5 in (12 mm).
- PetSafe OpenSky: “most clumping litter types.” Its user guide adds: “Litter with larger pellets, such as pine or tofu litter, may not be compatible with the litter box.”
- PetSafe SmartSpin: PetSafe’s sources don’t fully agree. The product page says it’s compatible with any litter and recommends premium clumping litter; PetSafe’s comparison chart lists clumping litter; and the user guide warns that litter with larger pellets, such as tofu litter, may not be compatible.
- CATLINK Open-X: the product description says any clumping litter works. An FAQ on the same page says clumping clay litter only, never crystal or silica gel litter, and to avoid lightweight litters. If you use tofu or another non-clay litter, ask CATLINK first.
Bags, liners, and other refills.
- Litter-Robot 4: Whisker says you can use regular trash bags. It recommends replacing the carbon filter every 2–4 weeks on its Litter-Robot 4 page and every month on its carbon filter page, though it says the timing is up to you and your cats’ use.
- Neakasa M1 Plus: Neakasa’s help center says, “We recommend using Neakasa brand garbage bags, which are more compatible with the cat litter box.” For other bags, ask Neakasa.
- PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2: PETKIT’s user manual says, “Please use the PETKIT specialized trash bag.” For other bags, ask PETKIT.
- PetSafe OpenSky and SmartSpin: both ship with waste bin liners (the SmartSpin also with two deodorizer packs; the OpenSky user guide also lists a deodorizer among the box contents).
- CATLINK Open-X: ships with a 20-liner roll. CATLINK’s FAQ also suggests replacing the litter completely every 2–3 weeks.
How often you empty the drawer or change the tray:
| Model | Drawer | Product page | User guide |
|---|---|---|---|
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | Crystal tray (disposable or reusable) | Up to 30 days per tray (no cat count) | 20–30 days per tray for one cat |
| PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 | 8 L | Up to 17 days for a single cat | Ask PETKIT |
| CATLINK Open-X | 12 L | Up to 15 days for one cat | Ask CATLINK |
| Neakasa M1 Plus | 11.23 L | About 14 days for one cat | Every 7 to 10 days for a cat, and no longer than 14 days; 7 days in hot summer weather |
| PetSafe OpenSky | 8.5 L | Up to two weeks for one cat | Once every 2 weeks for one cat |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | 6 L | Up to 2 weeks (no cat count) | About once a week for one cat |
| Litter-Robot 4 | Ask Whisker | About every 8 days for 1 cat (Whisker’s chart) | Ask Whisker |
Three user guides are more conservative than the product pages: the SmartSpin guide says about once a week for one cat, half the product page’s “up to 2 weeks”; the Crystal Pro guide gives a 20–30 day range for one cat rather than “up to 30 days”; and Neakasa’s manual says every 7 to 10 days for a cat, against about 14 days on its product page. The OpenSky guide’s once every 2 weeks for one cat is in line with its product page. Read every number here as a maker’s best case, and expect to empty more often with more or bigger cats.
We don’t publish prices because they change. Before you buy, price a few months of the litter or trays, bags, and filters the box needs. Our supplies guide by model lists the bags, trays, and filters for six of these seven boxes.
Decision 2: Open top or covered
Three of these models are open: the OpenSky, the Neakasa M1 Plus, and the CATLINK Open-X. The other four are covered in some way: the Crystal Pro has a removable hood, the SmartSpin is spherical, the Litter-Robot 4 is a globe, and PETKIT calls the MAX PRO 2 an enclosed design.
All three open-top makers pitch at big cats. PetSafe says the OpenSky accommodates cats up to 33 lbs. Neakasa recommends the M1 Plus for cats from 2.2 to around 33 lbs and says the open top gives breeds such as Maine Coons and Ragdolls room to turn around. CATLINK says the Open-X’s open design gives “even the largest cats” room. Covered doesn’t automatically mean small, though: Whisker says the Litter-Robot 4 suits cats 3–25 lbs, including large breeds such as Maine Coons, and its FAQ separately says the Litter-Robot 4 has no weight limit (our Litter-Robot 4 review covers both statements). PetSafe lists the SmartSpin for cats up to 25 lb, and PETKIT lists the MAX PRO 2 for cats 3.3–22 lbs.
Getting in. Each maker measures the way in differently:
- SmartSpin: PetSafe says it sits “just 12 in. from the ground.”
- PETKIT MAX PRO 2: an entrance height of 10.03 in.
- Neakasa M1 Plus: an entry height of 13.86 in.
- Litter-Robot 4: Whisker gives a step height of 6.9 in in its comparison chart, and an entryway of 15.75 in high by 15.75 in wide in its FAQ.
A step height, an entry height, and a height “from the ground” aren’t necessarily the same measurement. If the step in matters for your cat, measure your cat and ask the maker how its number was taken.
Floor space and placement:
| Model | Size the maker lists | Placement notes (maker) |
|---|---|---|
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | 28.2 x 20.4 x 16 in | — |
| PetSafe OpenSky | 20 x 18.8 x 24 in | — |
| Litter-Robot 4 | 22 x 27 in footprint, 29.5 in tall | Weight readings are most accurate on a firm surface. Whisker’s comparison chart says carpet requires its Carpet Tray add-on; the product page says the tray isn’t required for the box to work and improves weight readings on carpet 3 mm or thicker |
| PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 | 25.86 x 21.18 x 23.74 in (W x D x H) | Firm, level surface, not carpet; at least 2 in from the wall |
| CATLINK Open-X | 23.43 x 21.06 x 15.43 in in its shipping configuration | Avoid carpet; 6 in of clearance on all sides |
| Neakasa M1 Plus | 22.83 x 19.69 x 26.83 in (W x D x H), from the page’s product data* | — |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | Ask PetSafe | — |
*The product-data block that lists this size also describes fewer infrared sensors than the visible page, so it may be older text. Confirm the size with Neakasa if space is tight.
Switching boxes. PetSafe says some owners start by placing the new ScoopFree box next to the old one, putting it where the old one stood, or leaving it unplugged for the first few weeks. Neakasa suggests cleaning manually for the first few days with a timid cat, then switching on automatic cleaning. We have no data on whether your cat will prefer a top or no top.
Decision 3: App, Wi-Fi, and upgrades
- No app: PetSafe’s comparison chart lists no app for the Crystal Pro; the box has a usage counter instead.
- 2.4 GHz: Whisker says the Litter-Robot 4 needs a 2.4 GHz signal and doesn’t support 5 GHz. PetSafe lists 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi for the OpenSky and the SmartSpin; if your router uses only 5 GHz, ask PetSafe before you buy.
- 2.4 or 5 GHz: PETKIT says the MAX PRO 2 supports both bands, and CATLINK says the same for the Open-X.
- When the internet drops: Neakasa says the M1 Plus keeps working on your previous settings, and PETKIT says the same of the MAX PRO 2. In both cases the app doesn’t update your cat’s activity while the connection is down.
- Cleaning delay: PetSafe says you can set the OpenSky’s countdown after a visit from 1 to 60 minutes in the app.
App upgrades. Whisker says the free app shows a 7-day look at the Litter-Robot 4’s visits and cat weights, and a Whisker+ membership extends that to up to 4 years of history; a footnote on Whisker’s page adds, “Data retrieved starting from 2023” (checked November 8, 2026). PETKIT’s page says you can upgrade to PETKIT Care+ for 30-day video history on the MAX PRO 2. CATLINK charges a one-time in-app fee, below. Check each maker’s current terms; we don’t list prices.
Check the CATLINK version before you buy. CATLINK sells separate Multi-Cat and Single-Cat versions of the Open-X. CATLINK’s Multi-Cat page also carries a line saying the version “is designed for single-cat households only” and that multi-cat recognition can be unlocked in the app for a one-time fee. If you have more than one cat, ask CATLINK which version you’re getting and whether that unlock is included. Several Amazon listings carry the same CATLINK model number, so we don’t link one.
Decision 4: Kittens
| Model | Maker’s rule for kittens |
|---|---|
| Neakasa M1 Plus | 2.2 lbs or more for automatic cleaning; below that, Kitten Mode, which doesn’t clean automatically |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | User guide: unplugged, or Auto clean off in the app, and scoop by hand until at least 2.5 lb and 6 months old |
| Litter-Robot 4 | At least 3 lbs for automatic mode; under 3 lbs, Whisker suggests a “semi-automatic” routine with the unit powered off or unplugged |
| PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 | User manual: “Kittens younger than 6 months old are prohibited from using this device. Cats weighing less than 1.5 kg are prohibited from using this device.” If you also have adult cats, ask PETKIT how to set the box up |
| CATLINK (FAQ on the Open-X page) | Over 6 months old and at least 3.3 lbs; otherwise Kitten Mode, which turns off automatic cleaning |
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | User guide: unplugged, scooping by hand, until at least 6 months old |
| PetSafe OpenSky | User guide: “Leave the litter box unplugged and scoop waste manually (or turn off the Auto Clean feature in the app) until your kitten is at least 3 pounds (1.5 kg) and 6 months old.” |
Neakasa lists the lowest weight for automatic cleaning here. Kitten health questions belong with your veterinarian.
Decision 5: Where you buy changes whose terms apply
| Model | Amazon U.S. listing we link — seller on Nov. 3, 2026 | Terms on the maker’s own website |
|---|---|---|
| PetSafe Crystal Pro | Amazon.com | PetSafe: return within 45 days |
| PetSafe OpenSky | Amazon.com | PetSafe: return within 45 days |
| PetSafe SmartSpin | Amazon.com | PetSafe: return within 45 days |
| Litter-Robot 4 | Spreetail (a third-party seller) | Whisker: 90-day in-home trial and refund for purchases from Whisker’s own sites; bought anywhere else, the return goes through that seller under its policy; 1-year warranty |
| PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 | PETKIT-US | PETKIT: 2-year warranty for this model; the warranty covers purchases from petkit.com or authorized U.S. distributors |
| Neakasa M1 Plus | “M1 Plus Lite” listing (white), sold by Neakasa official | Neakasa: 30-day return and money-back guarantee; 2-year limited warranty |
| CATLINK Open-X | Not linked | CATLINK: 90-day returns; 1-year warranty |
The right-hand column is each maker’s terms for purchases on its own website. Before you count on them for an Amazon order — including orders from Amazon stores that use the brand’s name, such as “Neakasa official” or “PETKIT-US” — ask the maker whether they apply, including whether Spreetail or PETKIT-US counts as an authorized distributor. On Amazon, the listing’s own return terms and its “Ships from” and “Sold by” lines are what you go by.
About the Neakasa listing: Neakasa’s own site sells the M1 Plus. The Amazon listing we link is titled “M1 Plus Lite” (white) and is sold by the Amazon store “Neakasa official”; ask Neakasa or the seller what that package includes. We link only this listing: on Nov. 3, other Neakasa M1 listings on Amazon included ones that added a protection plan and renewed units. Neakasa’s site was also promoting a newer model, the M9, on Nov. 3; this guide covers the M1 Plus only.
Which design fits your situation
No app, and you’d rather swap disposable trays than handle litter and bags — and you’re fine buying PetSafe trays: PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro.
Check the PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro on Amazon
A cat that avoids covered boxes, PetSafe’s app, and clumping litter: PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky.
Check the PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky on Amazon
An open top with automatic cleaning from 2.2 lbs (the lowest kitten weight listed here): Neakasa M1 Plus. The Amazon listing we link is the white “M1 Plus Lite” listing.
Check the Neakasa M1 Plus Lite (white) on Amazon
An open top with 5 GHz Wi-Fi — after confirming the version: CATLINK Scooper Open-X.
See the CATLINK Scooper Open-X on CATLINK’s site
A covered globe, clumping clay litter, and regular trash bags: Whisker Litter-Robot 4. Our full review has the details.
Check the Litter-Robot 4 (White) on Amazon
A covered PetSafe box with an app and clumping litter: PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin.
Check the PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin (White) on Amazon
A covered box with 5 GHz Wi-Fi and a choice of sifter for coarse (tofu, mixed) or fine litter: PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2.
Check the PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 on Amazon
Before you buy: five checks
- Measure the spot, including the floor type and any clearance the maker asks for.
- Check your router. The makers list 2.4 GHz for the Litter-Robot 4, the OpenSky, and the SmartSpin; Whisker says the Litter-Robot 4 doesn’t support 5 GHz, and for the two PetSafe boxes, ask PetSafe if your router uses only 5 GHz.
- Pick the litter you’ll keep buying and check it against the maker’s rules — or accept PetSafe’s trays for the Crystal Pro.
- If you have a kitten, check the maker’s minimum weight and age.
- Check who sells the listing and whose return terms apply.
How we compared
We did not handle or test these boxes. We read each maker’s product page, FAQ, and policy pages on November 3, 2026 (Whisker’s Litter-Robot 4 FAQ on November 2), PetSafe’s Crystal Pro and SmartSpin user guides and its reusable-tray page on October 28, 2026, and the OpenSky user guide, the Neakasa and PETKIT user manuals, Neakasa’s bag help article, and Whisker’s carbon filter pages on November 9, 2026, and recorded the exact wording behind every figure here. We checked the Amazon U.S. listings we link on November 3 for model number and seller, not price. Makers’ performance claims, such as drawer capacity in days, are labeled as theirs. Where a table says to ask the maker, check with that maker before you rely on a figure.
Sources
- PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky product page (ZAL00-18120), including PetSafe’s three-model comparison chart
- PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro product page (PAL00-18017)
- PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin product page (PAL00-17985)
- PetSafe ScoopFree Crystal Pro user guide (PDF, checked October 28, 2026)
- PetSafe ScoopFree SmartSpin user guide (PDF, checked October 28, 2026)
- PetSafe ScoopFree OpenSky user guide (PDF, checked November 9, 2026)
- PetSafe ScoopFree reusable litter tray page (checked October 28, 2026)
- Whisker Litter-Robot 4 product page
- Whisker Litter-Robot 4 FAQ (checked November 2, 2026)
- Whisker carbon filter page (checked November 9, 2026)
- Whisker Litter-Robot 4 carbon filters page (checked November 9, 2026)
- Whisker Litter-Robot comparison chart
- Whisker return policy
- PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 product page
- PETKIT PUROBOT MAX PRO 2 user manual (PDF, V1.1, checked November 9, 2026)
- PETKIT warranty policy
- Neakasa M1 Plus product page
- Neakasa M1 user manual (PDF, checked November 9, 2026)
- Neakasa help center: “Is it necessary to use your brand of garbage bags?” (checked November 9, 2026)
- CATLINK Scooper Open-X product page
- Amazon U.S. listing model numbers and sellers: Amazon product data, November 3, 2026 (not a spec source)
We compared published specifications and manufacturer policies. We did not test these products. Product details, sellers and terms can change, so check the maker’s current pages and the seller before you buy. For questions about your cat’s health or litter box habits, ask your veterinarian.